Category: Opinions

Analysis of court opinions affecting beverage and cannabis businesses, including regulatory disputes, contracts, trademarks, and constitutional issues.

Beer cans in a warehouse beside a cancelled distribution agreement, with the headline Stale Beer. Lost Franchise. and a Throwback Friday label.

Throwback Friday: Thirty-Three Years of Distribution. Fifty-One Cases of Bad Judgment.

Thirty-three years of distribution could not save BeerMart after employees concealed the age of fifty-one cases of Schlitz. This Throwback Friday examines the Seventh Circuit decision, contrasting freshness disputes, and contract terms that help brewers and distributors keep stale beer from becoming a termination fight.

Beverage warehouse and promotion paperwork with a headline about Fedway and defending trade practice claims

Throwback Friday: What Fedway Teaches Suppliers and Distributors About Defending Against Trade Practice Claims

A valuable incentive. More sales. Fewer purchases from a competitor. Those facts alone don’t establish unlawful exclusion. This Throwback Friday, we revisit Fedway and explain how suppliers and distributors can challenge unsupported trade practice claims by demanding evidence of a potential threat to retailer independence.

Block v. Canepa graphic shows an Ohio wine shipment, courthouse, and producer, wholesaler, and retailer icons.

The Sixth Circuit Finally Lets the Retailer DTC Plaintiffs Win — But Block v. Canepa Is Not the End of the Three-Tier System

Retailer-shipping challengers prevailed in the Sixth Circuit’s Ohio case. The opinion illustrates why discriminatory shipping restrictions require an evidentiary defense and why that inquiry differs from a challenge to the three-tier system as a whole.

Man in apron gesturing and speaking to female police officer in uniform inside bar

The Fourth Amendment Walks Into a Bar: Federal Court Says Michigan’s Warrantless Liquor Inspection Law Is Unconstitutional. Your State’s May Be as Well

A Michigan bar’s challenge puts warrantless liquor inspections under constitutional scrutiny. The Generis Entertainment opinion examines limits on inspection scope and officer discretion, with practical questions for licensed businesses before an inspector arrives.