When California Tried to Tax Flavored Malt Beverages as Spirits
California’s tax board wanted to move some flavored malt beverages into the spirits column. That could raise the state excise tax from 20 cents to $3.30 per gallon. The can didn’t change. The board’s definition did. In 2012, a California appeals court said the board didn’t have the authority to write a different definition for tax purposes.
Originally published May 2, 2012. Updated November 22, 2026, with the repeal of the challenged rules and a look at today’s tax and labeling requirements.
What the California court actually decided
California’s Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) had long treated the flavored malt beverages at issue as beer for licensing and regulation, and the State Board of Equalization had taxed them accordingly. Then the board adopted a 2008 rule treating a non-wine beverage as distilled spirits if at least 0.5 percentage points of the finished drink’s ABV came from flavors or other ingredients containing alcohol distilled from fermented agricultural products. Companion rules presumed non-wine beverages fell in the spirits category and gave manufacturers a way to rebut that presumption.
Sacramento County Superior Court sided with the board on summary judgment. In its published opinion in Diageo-Guinness USA, Inc. v. Board of Equalization (2012) 205 Cal.App.4th 907 (PDF), the Third District reversed. Revenue and Taxation Code § 32002 carries the Alcoholic Beverage Control Act’s definitions into the tax law. The court held that ABC could interpret those definitions as needed, but the tax board couldn’t substitute its own. The tax law calls for coordinating California and federal beer and wine taxation where its terms permit, not treating federal approval as the answer to every state classification question. The appeals court sent the case back with directions to enter judgment for Diageo-Guinness and the Flavored Malt Beverage Coalition.
The California Supreme Court denied Santa Clara County’s request to depublish the opinion on August 29, 2012 (search docket S203691), and declined to take up the case on its own motion. The board formally repealed the six invalidated regulations, effective January 8, 2013.

What California taxes and what it wants on the label
The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, which collects the tax and administers the program in cooperation with the board, still lists the excise rates: beer at $0.20 per gallon and distilled spirits at $3.30 per gallon through 100 proof or $6.60 above that. For 31 gallons, the comparison runs from $6.20 for beer to $102.30 or $204.60 for spirits. The ruling didn’t decide which rate applies to every canned cocktail or every recipe containing an alcohol-based flavor.
California’s Business and Professions Code §§ 23005 and 23006 supply the starting definitions. Section 23006 expressly allows certain fermentation adjuncts and treats beer aged in an empty wooden barrel formerly used for wine or spirits as beer. Effective January 1, 2027, AB 2375 as enacted expressly adds other grain to the list and specifies drinkable water. None of that revives the board’s old tax threshold.
The half-point number still matters for a different reason. Under California Business and Professions Code § 25205, certain products approved for federal malt-beverage labeling also need an ABV statement and a conspicuous, front-facing “CONTAINS ALCOHOL” notice in bold capitals at least three millimeters high. That rule applies when at least 0.5 percentage points of the finished beverage’s ABV come from flavors or other ingredients containing distilled alcohol, and the manufacturer or importer sells the product to a California wholesaler or retailer. It governs the label, not the tax classification.
Check the formula before pricing the launch
Federal beer for excise tax purposes and a federal malt beverage for labeling purposes have different definitions. Under the federal limits on nonbeverage flavors, at 6% ABV or less, flavors and other nonbeverage ingredients can supply up to 49% of the finished drink’s total alcohol. Above 6% ABV, the alcohol they supply can make up no more than 1.5% of the finished drink’s volume. Those caps apply to nonbeverage ingredients, not to a shot of vodka added to a beer base.
Suppose a 5% ABV malt beverage with an approved federal label gets one percentage point of its finished ABV from a nonbeverage flavor containing distilled alcohol, with the other four from fermentation. That flavor supplies 20% of the drink’s alcohol, below the federal cap. The same one point clears California’s half-point threshold for the special label on a covered sale. Neither calculation, on its own, tells you what to put on the California excise return. Check the base, the finished ABV and each ingredient’s contribution before settling on the license, label and price.
For a different way a state handled the same tax question, see Nebraska’s court fight and the law Nebraska passed in response.













