Ohio H.B. 194 Counts Barrels. What About the Distributor?

Suppose the same brewery accounts for half a percent of one Ohio wholesaler’s sales and 15 percent of another’s. It makes exactly the same number of barrels either way. But one distributor loses a small line if the brewer walks, while the other has to replace a meaningful part of its business. The latest substitute for Ohio H.B. 194 looks at the brewery’s barrelage and gives the same answer in both cases. Ohio alcohol franchise law should start with a different question: What does the distributor stand to lose?

Why Ohio protected the distributor in the first place

Ohio adopted its Alcoholic Beverages Franchise Act in 1974. In Esber Beverage Co. v. Labatt USA Operating Co., 2013-Ohio-4544, ¶ 10, the Ohio Supreme Court quoted the original bill analysis: the Act aimed “to eliminate unfair practices by beer and wine manufacturers in their dealings with distributors.” The law served an antitrust purpose in a practical sense: it checked the leverage large producers could exercise over independent wholesalers. A wholesaler could spend years getting a beer onto shelves, building repeat orders, and putting trucks and people behind the brand. Without protection, the brewer could threaten to move the line once those accounts had value. Ohio still recognizes that investment in R.C. 1333.85(D): when a qualifying successor terminates a franchise under that provision, compensation for the diminished value of the distributor’s business includes “the goodwill associated with that product or brand.”

The barrel cutoff tells you whose problem H.B. 194 starts with. As introduced, the bill would have excluded producers making fewer than 250,000 barrels of beer a year from the definition of manufacturer. In April 2025 testimony supporting that version, the Ohio Craft Brewers Association argued that a single craft brewery typically accounts for only a small fraction of a wholesaler’s sales. That argument has force. The November substitute lowers the cutoff and adds compensation, but it still uses the brewer’s size as a proxy for how much the wholesaler depends on the brand. The hearing testimony gives Ohio a good reason to measure that dependence directly.

A better exit test: 1% of the wholesaler’s sales

Here’s what we’d put in the bill: If the supplier’s brands account for 1% or less of the affected distributor’s net Ohio beer and wine sales over the 12 months before notice, allow termination without cause, on written notice and with payment. Count brands under common control together so a supplier can’t take a larger business away one brand at a time. Above 1%, keep the ordinary franchise protections and their existing exceptions. New York already measures the wholesaler’s stake: its beer law pairs a brewery production ceiling with a 3% cap on the brewer’s share of the wholesaler’s annual brand sales and requires payment for the lost rights. Ohio could make the wholesaler’s stake the test in its own right.

The percentage tells you whether the supplier can leave without cause. The fair market value of the lost distribution rights, including the goodwill the wholesaler helped build, tells you what the supplier owes. We’d also require the supplier to buy back saleable stock. Even a brand that makes up less than 1% of a wholesaler’s sales has value; the point of the threshold is to limit the disruption an exit can cause, not to discount the work the distributor put in.

What an injunction protects that a buyout may not

The distinction between eligibility and payment matters because Ohio distributors have used injunctions to keep exclusive brands in place while courts decide whether the supplier can lawfully take them away. In Tri County v. Labatt, No. 2:13-cv-317, ECF No. 56, at 27–29, 31–32 (S.D. Ohio Oct. 16, 2013), the beer lines at issue accounted for about 41% of one wholesaler’s beer sales and 19% of the other’s. The court saw a risk to retailer relationships and sales of other brands, too. It blocked the transfers while the case proceeded, explaining that “injunctive relief is appropriate to maintain the status quo in the interim.”

H.B. 194 would not expressly bar injunctions. But if a supplier qualifies under the barrel cap and meets the bill’s other requirements, the distributor could no longer rely on the lack of just cause to stop the transfer, even if it stands to lose a major part of its business. A buyout might price the departing line without accounting for the retailer that takes the rest of its orders elsewhere. That’s why we’d measure the wholesaler’s stake and preserve the court’s ability to pause a transfer when the right to exit or compliance with the payment requirements is genuinely in dispute.

Could a barrel-only rule raise a Fifth Amendment takings question? The argument would be strongest if the state itself effectively transferred a vested exclusive right without just compensation. The same Labatt litigation shows the hurdle. The Sixth Circuit, 828 F.3d 421, 429–30 (6th Cir. 2016), rejected the challenge to Ohio’s existing successor-manufacturer exception: the Takings Clauses “deal with government takings of property,” and the suppliers acted privately. The court also treated protection against termination as a statutory right the legislature could change. Here, the substitute provides for payment, lets the parties expressly contract around the exit rule, and applies only to agreements made, amended, or renewed after it takes effect. That makes a takings claim an uphill fight. It still leaves the policy question: Why should the right to leave turn on what the brewer makes rather than what the wholesaler stands to lose?

What the substitute actually does

The Ohio House Judiciary Committee’s November 10 hearing record includes substitute L_136_3774. The bill remains in committee. Current Ohio law generally requires just cause and at least 60 days’ written notice to end or decline to renew a franchise without the other party’s consent, subject to exceptions such as the separate provision for certain successor manufacturers. Proposed § 1333.831 would give producers making 25,000 barrels or fewer of alcoholic beverages a year a way to terminate “for any reason or no reason,” ordinarily on at least 45 days’ written notice unless the agreement expressly provides otherwise. The Act defines alcoholic beverages as beer and wine, so the substitute reaches beyond the original bill’s beer-only production test.

The proposed section would apply to agreements made, amended, or renewed on or after its effective date. A brewery making 20,000 barrels a year could therefore pick up a statutory exit right by renewing an agreement after that date, even if the parties leave its wording alone. If the wholesaler expects the brewery still to need just cause, the parties should address that directly. A clause saying Ohio law governs simply sends them back to the statute.

The buyout clause could set the price

If the written agreement has no compensation method, proposed § 1333.831(D)(1) would give the wholesaler the fair market value of the terminated franchise and require the manufacturer to buy back saleable product in the warehouse or on its way to the wholesaler at laid-in cost. The parties would dispose of unsaleable product as they previously agreed, or split the disposal cost if they never reached an agreement on it. If the written franchise agreement does set a method or formula, § 1333.831(D)(2) instead points to the parties’ bargain.

Consider a wholesaler that took on a new market, staffed a route, and built repeat orders at retailers. A formula based on the prior year’s profit might put a low price on a franchise whose value is only starting to show up in sales. As we discussed in our look at the Coors distribution agreement, the definition of profit can matter as much as the multiplier. Specify the valuation date and deductions, who can see the supporting records, and whether the payment includes inventory. If there’s a separate buyback, say who picks up the stock, what happens to orders already in transit, and who pays to dispose of product that can’t go back on the shelf.

The second 45-day clock starts at termination

Even a carefully written formula won’t prevent every dispute. If the parties disagree about the amount, the bill would require the manufacturer to pay a good-faith estimate by the termination date and the wholesaler to make saleable inventory available for pickup. If the manufacturer underpays or pays nothing, the wholesaler would have 45 days after the effective date of termination to bring a claim for compensation, either in court or through an agreed dispute process. A wholesaler waiting for the supplier’s final numbers could use up much of that time before it even has the records it needs.

Before the next amendment or renewal, read the termination, payment, and inventory provisions together. What would the wholesaler have to show to get paid, and could it get those records in time? Those questions are easier to answer while both sides still want to sign the deal. The legislature has a related question to answer before it rewrites Ohio’s law: When a producer wants to leave without cause, how much of the distributor’s business would it take with it? The number of barrels coming out of the brewery can’t tell you that.

Ashley Brandt

Hi there! I’m happy you’re here. My name is Ashley Brandt and I’m an attorney in Chicago representing clients in the Food and Beverage, Advertising, Media, and Real Estate industries. A while back I kept getting calls and questions from industry professionals and attorneys looking for advice and information on a fun and unique area of law that I’m lucky enough to practice in. These calls represented a serious lack of, and need for, some answers, news, and information on the legal aspects of marketing and media. I've got this deep seeded belief that information should be readily available and that the greatest benefit from the information age is open access to knowledge... so ... this blog seemed like the best way to accomplish that. I enjoy being an attorney and it’s given me some amazing opportunities, wonderful experiences, and an appreciation and love for this work. I live in Chicago and work at an exceptional law firm, Tucker Ellis LLP, with some truly brilliant people. Feel free to contact me at any time with any issues, comments, concerns… frankly, after reading this far, I hope you take the time to at least let me know what you think about the blog and how I can make it a better resource.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.